Not so long ago, everyone in the UK was encouraged to go to university and, for as long as I can remember, a university degree was considered superior. But things are changing and many young people are opting for vocational training,  This has a lot to do with the fact that higher education is no longer free in this country and many young people don’t want to be saddled with debt for the rest of their lives. But it’s not just that – many degrees don’t equip you for the world of work. And that world is changing dramatically as technology advances and world circumstances change.

If you are thinking about going to university, whether as a school leaver or a mature student looking for a new career,  the first question to ask yourself is “Is a degree essential for what I want to do?” Of course, for some professions it is, but for others there can be alternatives.

Career choices are also changing and so if you don’t have your heart set on a dream career,  you might want to have a look at some new ideas. Fifty years ago things were very different.

In the ’70s, the most popular choices for undergraduates included engineering, medicine, teaching, government and finance, while vocational students tended to go for skilled trades, hospitality, secretarial and admin, healthcare,  and technical and industrial training .

Fast forward to the ’20s and a very different picture is emerging. Healthcare is still important, as is the business and finance sector, but the latter has seen a shift towards entrepreneurship and specialisation. IT,  including newer areas such as software development and cybersecurity is now one of the most popular fields for undergraduates.  And digital media and creative industries,  along with renewable energy and environmental science are high on the list.

Vocational training has evolved to include coding and web development which can be learned without taking a degree. Vocational training programs that offer training in data analysis, machine learning, and data visualization are also gaining traction.  Digital marketing and social media management have also increased in importance because of the growth of online marketing platforms. Some examples are training in search engine optimization (SEO), social media strategy, and content marketing. Many of these can be learned online, allowing students to get experience and qualifications in their spare time at a much lower cost than a degree.

Programmes training in renewable energy installation, energy efficiency, and sustainable technologies have also been developed because of the  the demand for skilled workers in the  industry.

It’s interesting to see that there is quite a bit of overlap, especially in areas such as business and marketing and IT, where it’s possible to get a well paid job or set up a lucrative business without going to university. Although it’s also true that some of the most successful entrepreneurs in the last fifty years didn’t go to university. So it’s not new, just more common!

If you’re unsure about whether or not to go to university, it’s worth thinking about the advantages and disadvantages.

Pros and Cons of University v Vocational Training.

As the job market evolves and the world we live in changes rapidly, young people and many adults are having to choose a career they will not only enjoy, but that is likely to be sustainable. And they face the question of whether to opt for university or vocational training to get the skills and knowledge that will make them employable. While both options can be fulfilling, exciting and lead to great opportunities,  they come with their own specific advantages and disadvantages. Let’s take a look at those in more detail to help you make a better choice.

University – the Advantages

University offers a great experience for personal growth – the chance to study something you really enjoy, make friends, enjoy the social life, as well as sports, acting and many other activities.

You’ll also develop some really important skills. These will vary according to your subject, but could  include critical thinking, report writing, communication skills,  analysis, time management, research, collaboration and teamwork, leadership, adaptability, presentation skills, the ability to learn independently and work on your own initiative, And all of those are in demand when it comes to finding a job.

More job opportunities  – some jobs require a degree, any degree, as a minimum requirement. This applies to some admin positions and  most government and civil service  jobs .Others require a specific degree, for example HR will ask for a degree in Human Resources (unsurprisingly!) or in a related field such as business admin, or psychology. Some jobs in financial services ask for degree in finance, accounting ,economics or a related field, because you’ll need the  technical knowledge and analytical skills those degrees will provide.

Networking  – you will meet people, including peers, lecturers and professionals  who could help your career in future.

Higher income  -_ generally speaking, graduates will earn higher salaries than non-graduates. But with so many opportunities for entrepreneurs these days, especially online, this could be changing!

University – The Disadvantages

Cost – this has to be the biggest disadvantage for many. If you don’t have wealthy parents, a college fund or the promise of a very lucrative job at the end of it, university means serious debt. You have to think about fees, accommodation and living expenses and all of this adds up to a frighteningly high amount.

Time – depending on the subject, your studies will take a number of years, meaning you’ll have to wait a while before earning any money.

Lack of practical skill – degrees tend to focus on intellectual stuff, knowledge rather than skills. And that can be a big disadvantage when you are applying for jobs. But it doesn’t apply to all degrees. So make sure you check out the subjects that interest you. For example, when I studied languages (a long time ago!), most degrees focused on literature and students wrote their dissertation in English, whereas the course I did concentrated on language and the dissertation, even though I chose literature, was written in Chinese!

Competition – because there are many more graduates these days, you’ll be up against more competition when you start applying for jobs at the end of your course.

Very general knowledge – some degrees will give you a very broad view of the subject, but you’ll need an advanced degree if you want to specialise, which means more money and more time.

Now let’s take a look at vocational training.

Vocational training – the Advantages

Specialised skill training – you’ll learn the practical skills you actually need to do the job

Up to date and relevant – because the courses are designed by industry specialists and not academics, these skills will be what the market is actually looking for.

Affordable – generally speaking, vocational training is a lot less expensive. You could, for example, have an apprenticeship where you learn on the job and in day release classes. And you’ll be paid. In the UK you will be entitled to the national minimum wage. So you won’t be rich, but you won’t be racking up huge debts.

Easier to find employment – you could well get a job with your current employer at the end of your apprenticeship, but even if you don’t you’ll be “job-ready”. Terrible expression, but it gets the point across!

Vocational training – the Disadvantages

Fewer transferable skills – such as communication skills, teamwork and critical thinking, because the focus is so much on practical skills

Job Loss – some practical jobs are becoming obsolete due to the advances in AI. So be sure to check if this applies before committing to training!

Less Flexibility – you’ll be qualified in a limited field and could have to retrain if you lose your job

Potentially lower earnings – this is true in some cases but not all. If there are opportunities for self-employment or starting your own business you could do very well.

Now that we’ve had a look at the advantages and disadvantages of university degrees and vocational training, it’s very clear: there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Everything depends on your own circumstances, interests, strengths, aspirations and personality.

The most important thing is to follow your own path – the path you want, not the path someone else wants for you. Think about where you want to be in ten or twenty years and how you will get there.  Whatever you choose, it won’t always be an easy ride and you’ll need commitment and resilience and the ability to adapt to change. Lifelong learning is crucial whatever field you are in, as it will enable you to develop your skills, learn how to use new technology and keep you employable.

Ultimately, success is not about status, money and how society views your job, It’s about how you feel about what you do and the satisfaction you get from work.